Further Clarification on Santa
January 11th, 2012
Thank you for all of the positive feedback on our parenting skills… you all know who you are! There was one snarky anonymous (of course) comment on the Santa post last night, so we disabled comments altogether. We have a blog for our family and closest friends, and I’m really thinking about going private again because whoever you are, even though you see a scrapbook of our kids’ lives, you don’t know Mike or me, and you don’t know my children. I’m happy to share the love that we have with you and maybe some ideas along the way, but you have no right to judge us because you don’t have context… you don’t live our story. I wasn’t even going to say that much, so I’ll leave it at that.
For further clarification, it was all we could do to make it through Christmas believing in Santa this year. As Noelle’s parents, we wanted her to believe in Santa as long as she wanted to, and as long as it was fun for her. She came to us daily and asked us detailed questions and she begged us to stop talking in riddles. She was continually frustrated that we wouldn’t just say “yes” or “no” to the big question that kept being asked. I refuse to blatantly lie to my girl, so I never gave her a straight answer (which the other half of the crowd thinks is probably wrong that I didn’t come right out and answer her the first times she asked). It was no longer fun for her, and it wasn’t fair to her not to know the difference between real and pretend. She was begging us to tell her the truth. It was breaking our hearts just to get through Christmas. She was exasperated. Truly. Noelle deserved to know the truth.
I asked Noelle this morning if she is happy that we told her the truth about Santa and this was her answer, word for word, “I’m happy you told me the truth about Santa because I misunderstood who brought me my presents, whether it was you guys or Santa. Now I know who to thank!” I’m not even kidding you, that’s what she said. She’s happy, healthy, responsible, and so excited and already looking forward to being sneaky with us next year (she gets WAY more pleasure out of giving than receiving, so this will be right up her alley)… hopefully she’ll remember Santa as a little childhood game that’s lighthearted and fun… so we’re good!
On anther note, kids are so impressionable at this age, they are trying to figure out who they are and what they believe, and if we out right lied to her about Santa, how could she believe us when we tell her the truth about Jesus? We would have no credibility and rightly so. We want our yes to be yes and our no to be no. She’s trying to figure out the world around her and needs us to be honest and trustworthy. Those character qualities are much more important to us than believing in something that is not real.
*Now that all that heavy stuff is out of the way, I’m pretty sure Anna Kate will never question the validity of Santa and roll with it until she’s 16, and then be all like, “Oh, I get it! That’s silly!” but if she asks over and over again, I’m not going to leave her frustrated. That’s not fair. Each child is so different, so it will be interesting to see how that unfolds.
